Your home’s security starts with strong, reliable locks. But what happens when you move into a new home, lose your keys, or experience a break-in attempt? Should you rekey your locks or replace them entirely?
For Florida homeowners, the decision between rekeying and replacing locks depends on security needs, cost, and the locks’ condition. In this guide, we’ll break down the differences, benefits, and when to choose one over the other.
What Is Rekeying?
Rekeying involves changing the internal pins of a lock so that an old key will no longer work. A locksmith reconfigures the lock cylinder and provides a new key—without replacing the lock mechanism.
When Should You Rekey Your Locks?
🔑 You recently moved into a new home – You don’t know who else might have a copy of the old keys.
🔑 You lost your keys – Prevents someone from using lost or stolen keys to enter your home.
🔑 Your home was recently rented or had contractors – Former tenants or workers may still have key copies.
🔑 You want a master key system – Rekeying can allow multiple locks to be opened with a single key.
🔑 Your locks are still in good condition – If there’s no damage, rekeying is a quick and cost-effective solution.
Pros of Rekeying:
✅ More affordable than full lock replacement
✅ Quick and easy process (usually takes under an hour)
✅ Enhances security without changing hardware
✅ Allows you to create a master key system
Cons of Rekeying:
⚠️ Doesn’t upgrade the lock’s strength or durability
⚠️ May not be possible if the lock is damaged or worn out
⚠️ Requires a professional locksmith (DIY kits exist but can be tricky)
What Is Lock Replacement?
Replacing a lock means removing the entire existing lock and installing a new one. This is a great option if your locks are outdated, damaged, or if you want to upgrade to high-security or smart locks.
When Should You Replace Your Locks?
🔒 Your locks are old, worn out, or damaged – Rust, corrosion, or malfunctioning parts make replacement the best option.
🔒 You want to upgrade to high-security locks – Smart locks, keyless entry, or reinforced deadbolts offer better protection.
🔒 There was an attempted break-in – A damaged lock may no longer provide full security.
🔒 You want a completely new look – Aesthetic reasons, such as matching a modern home style, may justify a new lock.
🔒 Your locks are incompatible with rekeying – Some locks cannot be rekeyed and require full replacement.
Pros of Lock Replacement:
✅ Increases security with modern technology (e.g., smart locks, biometric access)
✅ Provides a fresh start with brand-new hardware
✅ Can enhance the home’s curb appeal with stylish lock designs
Cons of Lock Replacement:
⚠️ More expensive than rekeying
⚠️ Requires more time and effort for installation
⚠️ May involve drilling or modifying doors for new lock types
Rekeying vs. Replacing: Which Is Best for Florida Homeowners?
Choose Rekeying If:
✔️ You recently moved in and want to prevent old key access
✔️ You want to secure your home after losing a key
✔️ Your locks are in good condition and don’t need upgrades
✔️ You need a quick and affordable solution
Choose Lock Replacement If:
✔️ Your locks are damaged, rusted, or outdated
✔️ You want to upgrade to high-security or smart locks
✔️ There was an attempted break-in, and your locks were compromised
✔️ You prefer a new style or function (e.g., keyless entry)
Additional Security Tips for Florida Homeowners
Florida’s climate and security concerns make lock maintenance especially important. Here are some tips to keep your home safe:
🔹 Check for rust and corrosion regularly – Florida’s humidity can cause locks to weaken over time.
🔹 Upgrade to weather-resistant locks – Stainless steel or brass locks hold up better in coastal areas.
🔹 Consider smart locks for added convenience – Remote access and keyless entry add an extra layer of security.
🔹 Use deadbolts on all exterior doors – A high-quality deadbolt protects against forced entry.
Final Thoughts: Which Option Is Right for You?
Both rekeying and lock replacement are effective ways to enhance your home’s security. If your locks are in good shape, rekeying is a fast and affordable solution. But if your locks are outdated or you want an upgrade, replacing them is the best investment.
Have you rekeyed or replaced your locks recently? Let us know in the comments what worked best for your home!
Royal Locksmith offers fast, reliable, and professional locksmith services to meet all your residential, commercial, and automotive security needs. Whether you’re locked out, need a new set of keys, or want to enhance your property’s security, Royal Locksmith is here to help with top-notch solutions and exceptional customer service. Located at 901 Barnett Drive, Suite 941-O, Lake Worth, Florida, Royal Locksmith serves the area with 24/7 emergency services. Contact them today at 561-933-5697 to experience expert locksmith services you can trust!